Some Ebola experts worry virus may spread more easily than assumed - LA Times

DODGERS
Live updates: Dodgers lead Cardinals, 2-0, in NLDS Game 4

Nation
Some Ebola experts worry virus may spread more easily than assumed

Some Ebola experts worry that the virus may spread more easily than thought -- through the air in small spaces, for example.
By DAVID WILLMAN contact the reporter NationMedical ResearchAfricaScientific ResearchDiseases and IllnessesEbolaU.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

Ebola researcher says he would not rule out possibility that the virus spreads through air in tight quarters
'There are too many unknowns here,' a virologist says of how Ebola may spread
Ebola researcher says he thinks there is a chance asymptomatic people could spread the virus

U.S. officials leading the fight against history's worst outbreak of Ebola have said they know the ways the virus is spread and how to stop it. They say that unless an air traveler from disease-ravaged West Africa has a fever of at least 101.5 degrees or other symptoms, co-passengers are not at risk.

"At this point there is zero risk of transmission on the flight," Dr. Thomas Frieden, director of the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, said after a Liberian man who flew through airports in Brussels and Washington was diagnosed with the disease last week in Dallas.

Three more people have been hospitalized in Madrid for possible exposure to the Ebola virus after a Spanish nurse tested positive for the virus.
Other public health officials have voiced similar assurances, saying Ebola is spread only through physical contact with a symptomatic individual or their bodily fluids. "Ebola is not transmitted by the air. It is not an airborne infection," said Dr. Edward Goodman of Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas, where the Liberian patient remains in critical condition.

Yet some scientists who have long studied Ebola say such assurances are premature — and they are concerned about what is not known about the strain now on the loose. It is an Ebola outbreak like none seen before, jumping from the bush to urban areas, giving the virus more opportunities to evolve as it passes through multiple human hosts.

Dr. C.J. Peters, who battled a 1989 outbreak of the virus among research monkeys housed in Virginia and who later led the CDC's most far-reaching study of Ebola's transmissibility in humans, said he would not rule out the possibility that it spreads through the air in tight quarters.

"We just don't have the data to exclude it," said Peters, who continues to research viral diseases at the University of Texas in Galveston.

lRelated
L.A. NOW
Ebola prevention in L.A. County: Officials will outline what's being done
SEE ALL RELATED
8

Dr. Philip K. Russell, a virologist who oversaw Ebola research while heading the U.S. Army's Medical Research and Development Command, and who later led the government's massive stockpiling of smallpox vaccine after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, also said much was still to be learned. "Being dogmatic is, I think, ill-advised, because there are too many unknowns here."

If Ebola were to mutate on its path from human to human, said Russell and other scientists, its virulence might wane — or it might spread in ways not observed during past outbreaks, which were stopped after transmission among just two to three people, before the virus had a greater chance to evolve. The present outbreak in West Africa has killed approximately 3,400 people, and there is no medical cure for Ebola.

"I see the reasons to dampen down public fears," Russell said. "But scientifically, we're in the middle of the first experiment of multiple, serial passages of Ebola virus in man.... God knows what this virus is going to look like. I don't."

CAPTION
Ebola crisis
John Moore / Getty Images
World Health Organization instructors watch as health workers in protective suits take part in a training session in Monrovia, Liberia.
CAPTION
Ebola crisis
John Moore / Getty Images
Matua Fallah waits to receive a ration of rice at a makeshift distribution center in Dolo Town, Liberia, in August.
CAPTION
Ebola crisis
John Moore / Getty Images
Relatives of a local government official are escorted from the West Point slum of Monrovia, Liberia, in August after unrest erupted in response to a government quarantine.
CAPTION
Ebola crisis
John Moore / Getty Images
Saah Exco, 10, lies in a back alley of Monrovia's West Point slum in August. The boy was one of the patients pulled out of a holding center for suspected Ebola patients when the facility was overrun by a mob.
CAPTION
Ebola crisis
John Moore / Getty Images
A resident looks from behind a gate during the Liberian government's 11-day Ebola quarantine in the West Point district of Monrovia.
Tom Skinner, a spokesman for the CDC in Atlanta, said health officials were basing their response to Ebola on what has been learned from battling the virus since its discovery in central Africa in 1976. The CDC remains confident, he said, that Ebola is transmitted principally by direct physical contact with an ill person or their bodily fluids.

Skinner also said the CDC is conducting ongoing lab analyses to assess whether the present strain of Ebola is mutating in ways that would require the government to change its policies on responding to it. The results so far have not provided cause for concern, he said.

The researchers reached in recent days for this article cited grounds to question U.S. officials' assumptions in three categories.

cComments
@dareisay Obama does so much damage it is a wonder he has any time to play golf.
GAIAPJ
AT 3:39 PM OCTOBER 07, 2014

ADD A COMMENTSEE ALL COMMENTS
288

One issue is whether airport screenings of prospective travelers to the U.S. from West Africa can reliably detect those who might have Ebola. Frieden has said the CDC protocols used at West African airports can be relied on to prevent more infected passengers from coming to the U.S.

"One hundred percent of the individuals getting on planes are screened for fever before they get on the plane," Frieden said Sept. 30. "And if they have a fever, they are pulled out of the line, assessed for Ebola, and don't fly unless Ebola is ruled out."

Individuals who have flown recently from one or more of the affected countries suggested that travelers could easily subvert the screening procedures — and might have incentive to do so: Compared with the depleted medical resources in the West African countries of Liberia, Sierra Leone and Guinea, the prospect of hospital care in the U.S. may offer an Ebola-exposed person the only chance to survive.

The deteriorating conditions in Africa make it more likely additional cases of Ebola will appear in the United States and officials are pushing for increased screenings at airports.
A person could pass body temperature checks performed at the airports by taking ibuprofen or any common analgesic. And prospective passengers have much to fear from identifying themselves as sick, said Kim Beer, a resident of Freetown, the capital of Sierra Leone, who is working to get medical supplies into the country to cope with Ebola.

"It is highly unlikely that someone would acknowledge having a fever, or simply feeling unwell," Beer said via email. "Not only will they probably not get on the flight — they may even be taken to/required to go to a 'holding facility' where they would have to stay for days until it is confirmed that it is not caused by Ebola. That is just about the last place one would want to go."

Liberian officials said last week that the patient hospitalized in Dallas, Thomas Eric Duncan, did not report to airport screeners that he had had previous contact with an Ebola-stricken woman. It is not known whether Duncan knew she suffered from Ebola; her family told neighbors it was malaria.

The potential disincentive for passengers to reveal their own symptoms was echoed by Sheka Forna, a dual citizen of Sierra Leone and Britain who manages a communications firm in Freetown. Forna said he considered it "very possible" that people with fever would medicate themselves to appear asymptomatic.

It would be perilous to admit even nonspecific symptoms at the airport, Forna said in a telephone interview. "You'd be confined to wards with people with full-blown disease."

On Monday, the White House announced that a review was underway of existing airport procedures. Frieden and President Obama's assistant for homeland security and counter-terrorism, Lisa Monaco, said Friday that closing the U.S. to passengers from the Ebola-affected countries would risk obstructing relief efforts.

CDC officials also say that asymptomatic patients cannot spread Ebola. This assumption is crucial for assessing how many people are at risk of getting the disease. Yet diagnosing a symptom can depend on subjective understandings of what constitutes a symptom, and some may not be easily recognizable. Is a person mildly fatigued because of short sleep the night before a flight — or because of the early onset of disease?

Moreover, said some public health specialists, there is no proof that a person infected — but who lacks symptoms — could not spread the virus to others.

"It's really unclear," said Michael Osterholm, a public health scientist at the University of Minnesota who recently served on the U.S. government's National Science Advisory Board for Biosecurity. "None of us know."

Russell, who oversaw the Army's research on Ebola, said he found the epidemiological data unconvincing.

Full Coverage

Deadly Ebola outbreak spreads in West Africa
READ MORE STORIES
"The definition of 'symptomatic' is a little difficult to deal with," he said. "It may be generally true that patients aren't excreting very much virus until they become ill, but to say that we know the course of [the virus' entry into the bloodstream] and the course of when a virus appears in the various secretions, I think, is premature."

The CDC's Skinner said that while officials remained confident that Ebola can be spread only by the overtly sick, the ongoing studies would assess whether mutations that might occur could increase the potential for asymptomatic patients to spread it.

Finally, some also question the official assertion that Ebola cannot be transmitted through the air. In late 1989, virus researcher Charles L. Bailey supervised the government's response to an outbreak of Ebola among several dozen rhesus monkeys housed for research in Reston, Va., a suburb of Washington.

What Bailey learned from the episode informs his suspicion that the current strain of Ebola afflicting humans might be spread through tiny liquid droplets propelled into the air by coughing or sneezing.

lRelated
L.A. NOW
Ebola prevention in L.A. County: Officials will outline what's being done
SEE ALL RELATED
8

"We know for a fact that the virus occurs in sputum and no one has ever done a study [disproving that] coughing or sneezing is a viable means of transmitting," he said. Unqualified assurances that Ebola is not spread through the air, Bailey said, are "misleading."

Peters, whose CDC team studied cases from 27 households that emerged during a 1995 Ebola outbreak in Democratic Republic of Congo, said that while most could be attributed to contact with infected late-stage patients or their bodily fluids, "some" infections may have occurred via "aerosol transmission."

Relatives pray over a weak Siata Johnson, 23, outside the Ebola treatment center at a hospital on the outskirts of Monrovia, Liberia. (John Moore / Getty Images)
Skinner of the CDC, who cited the Peters-led study as the most extensive of Ebola's transmissibility, said that while the evidence "is really overwhelming" that people are most at risk when they touch either those who are sick or such a person's vomit, blood or diarrhea, "we can never say never" about spread through close-range coughing or sneezing.

"I'm not going to sit here and say that if a person who is highly viremic … were to sneeze or cough right in the face of somebody who wasn't protected, that we wouldn't have a transmission," Skinner said.

Peters, Russell and Bailey, who in 1989 was deputy commander for research of the Army's Medical Research Institute of Infectious Diseases, in Frederick, Md., said the primates in Reston had appeared to spread Ebola to other monkeys through their breath.

cComments
@dareisay Obama does so much damage it is a wonder he has any time to play golf.
GAIAPJ
AT 3:39 PM OCTOBER 07, 2014

ADD A COMMENTSEE ALL COMMENTS
288

The Ebola strain found in the monkeys did not infect their human handlers. Bailey, who now directs a biocontainment lab at George Mason University in Virginia, said he was seeking to research the genetic differences between the Ebola found in the Reston monkeys and the strain currently circulating in West Africa.

Though he acknowledged that the means of disease transmission among the animals would not guarantee the same result among humans, Bailey said the outcome may hold lessons for the present Ebola epidemic.

"Those monkeys were dying in a pattern that was certainly suggestive of coughing and sneezing — some sort of aerosol movement," Bailey said. "They were dying and spreading it so quickly from cage to cage. We finally came to the conclusion that the best action was to euthanize them all."

david.willman@latimes.com

Copyright © 2014, Los Angeles Times
by TaboolaSponsored LinksFROM AROUND THE WEB
Please Don’t Retire At 62. Here’s Why.
The Motley Fool
17 Silver Vixens Who Will Have You Canceling Your Next Dye Job
Refinery29
Top 12 Hard To Watch Movies
Movieseum

NationPolitics
HealthcareBusiness
LIKE
86°
National Politics

Top News

POLITICS NOW
Gay marriage poses a dilemma for many Republican candidates
Maeve Reston Gay marriage may be a settled issue in as many as 30 states after Monday’s Supreme Court decision, but it still poses an existential threat to many Republican candidates, especially as the calendar turns to the 2016 presidential contest.
Ready, set, traffic: Fundraising politicians to swarm California
White House tries to back off from Biden comments on militant group
New polls: Kansas has GOP on defense in its bid to take Senate
President has a short list of potential attorney general candidates

NATION Obama says his economic vision will be a key issue in midterm election
POLITICS NOW Republican Walker gains in Wisconsin, Brownback struggles in Kansas
POLITICS NOW In blow to GOP, Kansas judges refuse to force Democrat onto Senate ballot
POLITICS NOW Court blocks parts of N.C. law that ended same-day voter registration
POLITICS NOW Midterm madness: The politics of snowmobiles and chickens
Top of the TicketVIEW THE BLOG
White House guard is down: Are Secret Service agents bored?
Easy prediction: 2014 elections will merely renew gridlock
Holder's enemies may cheer, but he is far from gone
FDR could not have survived the scrutiny media gave Gary...
Scotland will do better staying with Britain than going solo
We have no Theodore Roosevelt to face down today's...
There is no exit strategy to avoid a long fight against...
Congress will want war with Islamic State to be Obama's...
City liberals lose out to rural Republicans for control of...
History of economic exploitation still hinders black...
Hackers have no right to steal private images of celebrities
In gun world, giving an Uzi to a child makes perfect sense
Tea party voters could dump Mitch McConnell just by...
America survives Obama vacation; chattering pundits are...
African elephant slaughter nears tipping point toward...
James Foley beheading shows vicious barbarity of Islamic...
Should our cops be commandos?
Racial prejudice and militarized cops are a bad mix in...
While critics carp, airstrikes in Iraq prevent genocide
Robin Williams' 'spark of madness' let him...
U.S. is destined to remain stuck in the sands of the...
Bad news in Gaza, Iraq and D.C., but good news in Botox...
Religion has taken center stage in America's...
U.S. can be a global winner by going lean on energy...
Immigrant kids bring out the phobias in conservative...

Keeping options open, Mitt Romney alters reality on 47% remark
Cathleen Decker
Would-be presidential candidates often keep their options open in defiance of reality, which perhaps explains why Mitt Romney, who has twice lost presidential bids, has been making a few hints that he may not be done seeking the White House.

Intruder ran farther into White House than previously disclosed
Valerie Jarrett's appearance on 'Good Wife' in works more than a year
Key U.S. Senate races close, new round of polls says
As election nears, control of Senate looks surprisingly uncertain
White House defends Secret Service after report on 2011 shooting
The White House defended the Secret Service on Sunday in the wake of a newspaper investigation that details how the agency fumbled its response to a gunman firing upon the White House in 2011, while President Obama's younger daughter and his mother-in-law were inside.

Early voting is changing election 'day' into election 'month'
Clintons 'blessed, grateful' over birth of grandchild
Bill, Hillary Clinton are grandparents: Chelsea gives birth to a girl
Indian leader's fast is etiquette question for dinner at White House
Extras
VIEW ALL DEALS
40% off Manhattan, NYC Westin starting at $183 - from Travelzoo VIEW OFFER
Save $879 on Norway northern lights cruise - from Travelzoo VIEW OFFER
L.A. hotel near Universal Studios including extras for $388 - from Travelzoo VIEW OFFER
Great ReadsVIEW MORE
Great Reads
He's no longer a prisoner of the war on drugs
SCIENCE For him, satellite reboot is about reconnecting with an old friend
GREAT READS Mark Hall-Patton, expert on TV's 'Pawn Stars,' is the real deal
HealthcareVIEW MORE
Wal-Mart to end healthcare coverage for 30,000 part-timers
Retail giant Wal-Mart Stores Inc. is cutting healthcare benefits for roughly 30,000 part-time employees, citing rising costs.

L.A. County offers $61-million health plan for those still uninsured
Los Angeles County will provide access to a primary care doctor for nearly 150,000 uninsured Los Angeles County residents, including many who are ineligible for Obamacare coverage because they lack legal immigration status.

Weigh options when losing health coverage at work: COBRA or Obamacare?
When Amanda Lean decided to leave her full-time job to work as a private political consultant, she had a decision to make: continue with the insurance she had through her previous job — or shop for a plan on her own.

California regulators clear Obamacare rates, hold off on networks
Obamacare doctor networks to stay limited in 2015
Number of Latinos with insurance coverage surges under healthcare law
White House reassessing Obamacare enrollment goal for 2015
30,000 Californians face Obamacare enrollment delays, dropped coverage

MEMBER CENTER
PLACE AN AD
LOCAL
SPORTS
ENTERTAINMENT
NATION
WORLD
BUSINESS
OPINION
LIFESTYLE
TRAVEL
AUTOS
REAL ESTATE
JOBS
PHOTOS & VIDEO
GREAT READS
CLASSIFIEDS
SHOP
ADVERTISING
CORRECTIONS
PRIVACY POLICY
TERMS
SITE MAP
ABOUT US
CONTACT US
©2014 LA TIMES