The CDC’s Theme on Housing Type and Transportation is shown on the map above. It is about types of buildings and how crowded the living space is. Single family homes, mobile homes, multi-unit buildings, homes with more people than rooms, and households without a vehicle are combined to make a social vulnerability score for the Housing Type and Transportation Theme.  The colored icons on this map tell you where each census tract falls on the vulnerability scale when the housing stock and access to a vehicle are looked at together.

 The darkest shade of blue represents the highest vulnerability.  The lightest shade is low vulnerability. Click on any icon to read the percentages in each category that contributes to Housing Type and Transportation vulnerability.

There is a decimal number that appears at the top of the box that appears on the left when you click on an icon. It is a decimal number between 0 and 1. The larger that number is, the higher the vulnerability is in that census tract.

If you click on the colored polygons on the map, you can read  comments made on the surveys by people who live, worship or work there.

 

Data Requested at Community Meetings

Suncoast ALICE Report: This United Way Report on the population of Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed people covers the State of Florida.

Sarasota, Florida Rental Rate Comparisons by Neighborhood

Recently Approved Affordable Housing: Note that these affordable housing units are for 80% of the Area Mean Income ($61,750), 100% of AMI ($77,200) and 120% of AMI ($92,640).

Dr. Kristopher Fennie Presents Survey Data on Housing

Raising Community Voices from survey comments and community dialogue exploring potential solutions

Community Voice Questionnaire

Housing Responses

2021

Definitions

Affordable Housing: any unit that costs 30% or less of household income.

Area Median Income (AMI): the midpoint of a region’s income distribution. Half of households in a region earn more than the median and half earn less than the median. A household’s income is calculated by its gross income, which is the total income received before taxes and other payroll deductions.

In 2018, the area median income in Sarasota-Bradenton-North Port was $70,300 for a household and $39,400 for an individual.

Moderate income: households earning between 80% and 120% of AMI 

Low income: households earning 80% or less of AMI

Very low income: households earning 50% or less of AMI

Extremely low income: households earning 30% or less of AMI

Workforce Housing: housing that’s affordable for members of the workforce

Attainable Housing: households earning between 60% and 120% of AMI

Are you worried about losing your housing?

  • Yes 20% 20%
  • No 73% 73%
  • N/A 7% 7%

Stress is when someone feels tense, nervous, anxious, or can’t sleep at night because their mind is troubled. How stressful is this for your family: Concerns about the cost of your housing?

  • 0 – The issue is not applicable to my family 16% 16%
  • 1-Not at all stressful 34% 34%
  • 2 – a little stressful 12% 12%
  • 3 – moderately stressful 19% 19%
  • 4 – very stressful 0% 0%
  • 5 – extremely stressful 5% 5%

How many times have you moved in the last year?

  • One 13% 13%
  • Two 10% 10%
  • Three 6% 6%
  • Four 3% 3%
  • Five 0% 0%
  • None 64% 64%
  • Other 4% 4%

What is your housing situation today?

  • I have housing. 72% 72%
  • I do not have housing (staying with others, in a hotel, on the street, in a shelter, living outside on the street, on a beach, in a car, or in a park) 23% 23%
  • prefer not to answer 5% 5%

Which of the following, if any, describe a problem with your housing situation? (Check all of the below that apply.)

  • bugs or rodents 11% 11%
  • general cleanliness 5% 5%
  • landlord disputes 8% 8%
  • mortgage disputes 2% 2%
  • lead paint 2% 2%
  • unreliable utilities 5% 5%
  • medical condition that makes it difficult to live in current house 0% 0%
  • mold or dampness 5% 5%
  • overcrowding 2% 2%
  • threat of eviction 3% 3%
  • none of the above 55% 55%

Comments Made About Housing

2021

My home is owned.   (Lives in E, Worships and Works in F)

Good (Lives in North Sarasota, Worships and Works in A)

Homeless housing experience (Worships in D)

Its expensive to live here (Lives and Worships in North Sarasota)

Need more rooming houses, affordable housing (Worships in D)

I am applying for HUD. (Lives in North Sarasota.)

I’m homeless.

Homeless with a young son; so, not eligible for family programs. (Lives in North Sarasota)

I wish I had housing. (Lives in D)

We need more affordable housing, especially for the elderly. (Lives in A)

Where you live depends on cost. There’s no public bathrooms in the area. (Lives in E)

Currently homeless but living with my daughter. It would be nice if there was affordable housing for frontline workers—police, firemen, teachers. (Worships and Works in B)

Need more housing, single family units. (Lives in B, worships in E)

Too expensive to buy home based on income. (Worships in B) 

Me and my mom live together (Lives in E)

Worried about housing costs increasing to where will not be able to afford it (Lives and worships in North Sarasota, and works in B)

Until I can go back to work, we are on one income. It’s a little stressful since we had to pay car notes, car insurance, lights, water, daycare ($180 a week), gas, etc. and we had to pay a plumber and roof damage plus the lawn (Lives in B, worships in E)

It is hard to find affordable housing (Lives in B, worships in E)

I pay $1600 monthly for rent and the landlord wants to raise it to $1850 per month (Lives and worships in B)

There’s not enough affordable housing for low-income earners (Lives in B, worships in E)

First-time home buyers at all-time low; need better jobs/skills for market area (Lives and worships in B, works in A)

Rent is not affordable (Lives in E, works in North Sarasota)

Hard to get roof fixed (Lives, worships and works in A)

Looking for housing; waiting for HUD voucher (Lives in C, works in A)

Rooming with someone. Income is not enough to live well. (Lives in B, worships in North Sarasota)

Housing is too expensive; affordable housing would be a 2-bedroom apartment for $800-1000/mo. instead of $1500 or a home for $150-200K instead of $300K (Lives and worships in North Sarasota)

More kid friendly places like Janie’s Garden (Works in A)

 

Housing Stories

Tenants’ Council Active in HUD Housing

Ms. Rachel Johnson (Faces of HUD Housing Unity Project) Rachel grew up in HUD housing with her mother and 3 brothers. It was multi-family Section 8 housing. Rachel is an advocate for low income housing tenants. She is focused on helping others make everything right through her advocacy organization. She fights against stereotyping, raises up needs and works to defend tenants’ rights. Rachel’s mother worked for the police department as a Community Service Aid. She helped organize residents within the HUD Section 8 housing. Rachel was, at one point, served with a 3 day notice to move out of Section 8 Housing. She was accused of fraud and had to defend herself. She fought and won the investigation, but was still evicted from housing, placing her in a hotel with her children. Rachel works to make the existing policies work. There is a policy called RAD, which stands for Rental Assistance Demonstration. It states that tenants are supposed to have input into mangement of HUD housing. Ms. Valerie Buchand serves in the role of organizing tenants so they have a unified voice for advocacy. Many HUD housing complexes are unsafe, have domestic violence and late utility check issuance. In the Sarasota Housing Authority, attempts to evict have begun. Rent subsidies are being removed and rents are going up to market value. Workers are mistreating tenants and violating the rights of tenants. 24 CFR 964 Regulations for HUD public housing say that tenants can have service coordinators, hire bookkeepers to help them, provide $25/door, vending machines and that if a developer comes in, tenant councils should be able to have agreements so they can recover from the developer impacts. Also at the Sarasota Housing Authority, tenant suggestions on how dollars should be spent are not being heard. Rachel helps Tenants’ Councils by developing Customer Service Champions, and helping the homeless and displaced. She helps people who are being mistreated and informs people about what the processes and procedures are as they try to work with the Housing Authority. With COVID there have been evictions and Section 8 housing has not been available. Housing has been terminated. Police officers come to HUD units, and armed security guards physically move people out. One woman with COVID was locked into her unit. There have been illegal evictions, and there have been offers of money to people for moving that is never paid. Rachel feels that cities and counties should do oversite. Tenants should not be charged for normal wear and tear. People should not be put out of housing with a 90 day voucher, because if they can’t find housing in 90 days they are homeless or displaced. CARES Act Rental Assistance is not available for Section 8 tenants. It is regarded to be “double dipping.” The CRAs did not understand how to help tenants with CARES Act funding. Only 30% went to tenants. 70% went to landlords. Housing Authorities have their doors closed, and automated services are on. People have less income due to COVID & can’t get their rents recalculated. Rent reimbursement is not retroactive. The disputes are in court and people have to pay back. Valerie and Deb are the Resident Commissioners. They say that Black people are being displaced from their jobs and White people are replacing them. Tenants who speak up are retaliated against or harassed. There is a “Just Cause Clause’ which says that every effort must be made to prevent people from losing their housing. Two things are happening: 1: A tenant is losing housing=evicted, and 2)An evicted tenant goes to a shelter to get another voucher. There is a need for people to stay on their vouchers so others in need can apply and there will be more vouchers available instead of the same people taking new vouchers. There are Source of Income Discrimination Laws. These prevent landlords from denying a tenant with a Section 8 voucher. There is re-entry assistance for returning felons and there are loopholes that prevent them from being housed. There can be MOAs between Resident Councils and Housing Authorities. Residents want incentives. The Housing Authority doesn’t want to pay, so they hold up the MOA. Grievance proceduree: Developer Agreements should increase the money available to tenants. The agreements can: pull from Section 8 voucher lists, help with displacement and homelessness, provide case management for the people, help people with mental disabilities by using just cause to use every way possible to keep people housed. There is fraudulent activity. Old stoves are installed in units instead of new stoves and it can cause fires. There are violations of tenants’ rights. Tenants can be Black balled. Rachel helps tenants to organize because HUD recognizes Tenant Coulcils’ need to have input into Housing Authority processes. Resources are not available to help people get out of Section 8 housing. Valerie Buchand’s Residents’ Coumcil is among the best in the state. Valerie’s Council has a 1 – 3 year plan. The paperwork was not done correctly so the Residents’ Council’s recommendations did not advance. “They wanted to ignore us.” Our workers were pushed out of jobs and Towers is mistreating our elderly. Rachel is working on briefings and a press conference with the Secretary of HUD, and is also working on a Saving Our Homes Tour together with their ally Florida Rising. They will petition the Secretary of HUD to meet with the Residents’ Council. Workers are in distress and the Board has oversight. Although it may look pretty on the outside, decisons that have to be made may be tough. Rachel Johnson Housing Advocate 863-500-2592. Email: facesofHUDHousing@gmail.com (also a FB Group)

 

 Website designed  by Heron Bridge Education, LLC for Health Initiatives Foundation, Inc. (2020)

 

 Copyright © 2020 AGRR Initiative, Health Initiatives Foundation, Inc., All Rights Reserved